Can Dubai Come Back?

by Charles Krakoff on July 14, 2009

in Crisis, Middle East, The Markets

It’s official: the recession has hit the United Arab Emirates, especially Dubai, hard. Well, maybe not official official, but I’m convinced. It’s not always easy to tell what’s happening in that part of the world. With rampant intermingling of public and private funds and  little transparency over who owns and owes what, appearances can be deceiving.

Most of the economic and business numbers have been pretty grim, but losses can easily be moved around, as in a game of three-card monte. For every big real estate project mothballed or scrubbed during the past six months, other highly visible  projects like the Dubai Metro have continued apace, and new ones are still being announced. Even as property values started to spiral downwards and huge property companies began to look distinctly wobbly towards the end of last year, there was still so much cash sloshing around and so many big projects still being announced and built the picture was pretty unclear.

Dubai, which has built a gleaming 21st-century economy based on real estate, trade, and services literally on a patch of desert sand,  has for so long defied common logic and perhaps even the laws of physics, and has produced such contradictory news since the onset of the financial crisis and recession, we might as well have tried to figure things out by reading our coffee grounds.

When the UAE government in February announced a new $100-billion project to build 80,000 new housing units in Dubai and Abu Dhabi to accommodate rising demand, there was at least a temptation to suspend disbelief. When the chairman of a large industrial group in Sharjah was quoted as saying that industrial investment was booming: “Recently, investors have been keen to invest in new areas. A lot of these investors have chosen the industrial sector, increasing the number of licenses, industrial facilities, workers, and types of industrial facilities. This clearly shows that the UAE is not exclusive to real estate investment, but is also active in all sectors,” I thought maybe there was something to his argument.

Turns out, there was not. A recent UAE-wide poll revealed that one in ten people in the country have lost their jobs over the past six months. Half of those polled said their companies have cut their workforce and a quarter say some of their co-workers have been required to take unpaid leave.

The real scale of job losses may be even higher. The UAE economy is built on an expatriate work force, ranging from Bengali and Pakistani laborers to highly-paid American and European investment bankers.  Only 20 per cent of the total population of around three million are citizens; most of the rest are there on temporary work permits. If you are a non-citizen the law requires you to leave within a month if you lose your job. This gives the UAE economy a safety valve of sorts by reducing unemployment compensation claims, but it can also have a devastating ripple effect as the job losses in the hardest-hit sectors – construction and property – produce more losses in a whole range of other industries. At the beginning of this year some analysts feared that the UAE population might drop by as much as eight per cent. Now this seems optimistic.

In what may be the most telling sign, the expected completion date of the Burj Dubai, the world’s tallest building, has been pushed back from September to December. The developer, Emaar, has been close-mouthed about the details, and is trying to get itself acquired by Dubai Holdings, though the financial situation of Dubai Holdings is hard to read, given the proportion of its assets held in land, most of which has probably not been marked to market. Other property companies are also said to be trying to merge. And Nakheel, another huge property company, which two years ago acquired the QE2 for £50 million, has temporarily abandoned plans to refurbish and reopen it as a luxury floating hotel moored to Palm Island, and now intends to send it back out on the high seas.

True, it’s not all about property. The overall UAE economy, of which oil still accounts for a third, is expected to contract by only 1% this year, and could well rebound in 2010. This may, however, signal a shift in the economic center of gravity back to Abu Dhabi, which produces about 85% of the Emirates’ oil and which has always dominated politically. But even if oil keeps the UAE economy from sinking, the boom times are unlikely to return soon. Until then, I would give investments there a fairly wide berth. Given the interlocking nature of UAE companies, when you buy a share of one  it’s hard to know who else’s hidden risks and liabilities you’re buying too.

Still, if Dubai’s recent history tells us anything it’s that anything is possible. If you can get British tourists to fly halfway around the world to lie on a beach in 120-degree heat this is literally true. So I wouldn’t entirely write off Dubai. Certainly not yet.


{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

Ali July 29, 2009 at 10:53 am

You’re correct, Dubai cannot be written off entirely. The reason is the abundance of cheap labor from Third World countries, who, in-spite of the meager paying jobs and horror stories of worker abuse, will continue pouring into the country to escape the desperation of poverty in their own. The same countries also offer a convenient brain-drain, of their talented and well-off citizens, who want a second home-base which is better developed and also nearby; this will ensure a constant demand for real-estate. Dubai is the only destination to the mid-east and the sub-continent that can offer the rich and affluent in places such as Pakistan, India, Iran and neary-by arab countries like Egypt, a safe and secure home away from home. Add the abundant supply of cheap labour in construction, services and hospitality (e.g. a construction worker in the US, who would work 12 hours per day for 365 of the year, can earn in excess of 100K. The same worker from India or Bangladesh earns less than $500/month in a place like Dubai).
Dubai wants to position itself as the Hong Kong of the mid-east; a financial and services-based economy. The people it wants to attract are the ultra-rich jet-setters from across the globe. It has the sandy beaches, palm trees and human slaves to make that happen.

Leave a Comment

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: